The Big CON.
The Raleigh metro area is booming, both in it’s population and economic growth. But like much of America, it has a familiar problem; it’s population is aging. An aging population needs healthcare. Not just offices in outpatient facilities (it needs those too), but it needs more hospitals and surgical centers. The southwest area of Raleigh metro in particular is a hospital desert. Patients here must be transferred to facilities dozens of miles away– unusual when you consider that the area is a booming tech hub. This is a truth that pretty much any local resident can tell you; this area desperately needs hospital beds.
In to this void stepped one of the regional healthcare market giants, Duke health with a proposal for a modest 120 bed facility in West Cary. Things were looking good, the local community appeared receptive of both the additional healthcare access to it’s aging population and the additional jobs that would be created. The land was found. Plans were drawn up, much fanfare and merriment were had. But before the overpaid CEO could dip his shovel into ceremenial dirt the plan was stopped in it’s tracks. What happened? The hospital expansion was the latest victim of America’s Certificate of Need (CON) system.
In the 1970’s it was widely felt by the political elite that central planning and rationing of healthcare facilities were needed to reign in spiraling healthcare costs. At that time America had gone through a boom cycle of hospital construction post WW2 that was seen as burning through Medicare’s budget. A hospital bed opened, would be a hospital bed occupied they thought, because the Medicare incentives were such that (unlike today) all admissions, all surgeries were paid for on a Cost Plus basis. Because if doctors said a patient needed a bed in a hospital, that admission must be necessary. What a weird thought, right? Central planning was needed to slow these costs, the thinking went. Then in 1974, the federal government mandated that all states have CON laws on the books.
All the big lobbies immediately backed the move, especially the AHA, the American Hospital Association, who saw it as a way to prevent competition against it’s own established hospitals. They quickly lobbied states to help create, fund, and occupy the boards that were necessary for CON certification. When NC’s Healthcare Planning and Certificate of Need (HPCON) Section holds hearings on potential CON actions, they are the ones who show up and argue against hospital expansion. In effect, this allows incumbent hospitals to prevent competition against them. And it’s all wrapped up in a state sponsorship with a bow on top.
In state hearings on potential new CON, they are usually the most vociferous.
“This new hospital will hurt our business!” they will shout; “and that will hurt patient care” they will scream. “We will have to compete harder for staff and that will endanger patient care!” they will cry.
All of this has the obvious effect of reducing competition, and directly increasing costs. Medicare no longer uses it’s fee-for-service model for admission, so the old adage “a bed made is a bed occupied” no longer holds true. Hospitals have to show a minimum level of illness to justify admissions. And as any doctor can tell you, even then many insurers will deny a legitimate admission. By the 1980s the pendulum had swung the other way as far as insurance coverage for hospital admissions goes. Through the 1980s multiple studies showed that CON laws increase healthcare costs. The DOJ argued that CON laws restrict output, suppress competition, and deny patients access to innovative, lower-cost care settings
Even the FTC has stated that CON laws suppress competition and promote the creation of local monopolies. In 1986 DC realized the error of it’s ways and repealed the CON law mandate. 14 states followed Washington’s lead.
36 states kept them on the books. Why? I know what you’re thinking. “It’s because of money and corruption, right?” Well, you’re wrong.
Actually, just kidding you’re right. It’s because of money and corruption.
Big Hospital is now part of the CON law infrastructure, and big lobbying money to local politicians is a small price to pay to basically keep the CON boards in place and block any competition from entering their markets.
Ultimately, isn’t it up to the local people to determine whether they could use additional healthcare facilities? Shouldn’t the economics of supply and demand determine whether a local business that is willing to invest billions be successful? Right now in 36 states including North Carolina, neither the community, nor the business that is willing to take a chance gets a say.
